If I can cook it, you can cook it And I'll travel the world to bring it back home to you.

The Ultimate Inexpensive Dinner Party Dish: Sheet Pan Lemon Chicken with Roasted Fingerling Potatoes

The Ultimate Inexpensive Dinner Party Dish: Sheet Pan Lemon Chicken with Roasted Fingerling Potatoes
Martha Stewart: Sheet Pan Expert
For some time I’ve been intrigued by the concept of the Sheet Pan dinner. Basically all the ingredients—protein, vegetables, herbs and spices–are cooked on one large sheet pan.  Martha Stewart seems to be an expert in this regard.  She frequently posts all kinds of options. There seems to be no end to what ingredients she’s managed to load onto one of these workhorse’s of the kitchen.  From Fish to Pork to Rib Eye, there’s no stopping Martha.   So I decided to cook one myself.  I adapted a recipe of mine for Lemon Chicken.  I added fingerling potatoes to the mix so in the end all I had to add to dinner were some sautéed green beans.   What I discovered was one of the best and most economical ways to entertain ever.  I honestly don’t think this dinner cost more $30.  And we fed 14 people with it and there were leftovers!  This is ideal for people on a budget, for recent grads who are neophytes in the kitchen and for people who just want to have a lot or people over without breaking the bank this holiday season. It all comes together in an hour and fifteen minutes.

Use this diagram to cut a chicken in 10 pieces
Martha recommends using a non-stick sheet pan.  I found that my ordinary sheet pan and heavy duty Reynold’s Wrap achieved the same effect:  Lessening the clean-up.  This is an expandable recipe. You can scale it up or down to whatever quantities you need.  If you follow this recipe to a Tee, you will also need a second sheet so be prepared. I used 3 whole chickens. These 3-3-1/2 lb. birds I then cut into 10 pieces. Cutting up your own chicken is the most cost-conscious way to make this dish.  The chicken ran 1.39 a lb. and the three of them cost all of $12 and change.   However, feel free to spring for three cut-up chickens, if butchering chicken is not your idea of fun.  You can even go for just thighs and breasts.  But for purposes of this recipe – that is feeding 12 to 14 people– stick to the weight of the chicken in the recipe whatever parts you choose to use.
The way to achieve as much flavor as possible is to really go all out with the quantities of lemon, garlic and herbs.  It may seem that a head of garlic, sliced, is an outrageous amount, but it’s not.  Similarly, the lemons seem out of line but the entire recipe hinges on getting a really lemon-y chicken at the end.  Cooking the potatoes under and around the chicken gives them a lot of chicken and lemon flavor too.   All in all, I can’t say enough good things about this recipe.  Do share it with your college grad or grad student or whoever you think can use it. Here is the recipe:


1 thought on “The Ultimate Inexpensive Dinner Party Dish: Sheet Pan Lemon Chicken with Roasted Fingerling Potatoes”

  • This is so simple, and you are right, it includes everything. More importantly, the cut up chicken that resembles a chicken weightlifter man, cinched it! You crack me up with your lively blog, love it! Thanks Monte 😀

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.