If I can cook it, you can cook it And I'll travel the world to bring it back home to you.

The Perfect Baked Potato from America’s Test Kitchen

Not too long ago, I happened upon an America’s Test Kitchen show on PBS. One segment featured their take on The Perfect Baked Potato.  There it was in all its simplicity:  Stabbed, Brined, Baked, Coated with Olive Oil, Baked again only to emerge in a flawless-looking potato which, when cut open stem to stern, released its steam and revealed the fluffiest interior I’d ever seen.  To this butter was quickly added melting into the potato as a fork whipped it up.  This lily was then gilded with great dollops of Sour Cream that was then topped with crispy bacon and a shower of chives. Perfection on a plate.  I couldn’t wait to bake my own but first I wanted a taste of the baked potatoes that come from a food cart that’s parked daily in our neighborhood.

On Broadway, in front of one of the big box stores that dominate our stretch of the famous boulevard, sits “CartOshka”, a food cart that specializes in Baked Potatoes. I am not sure I know when it first arrived. I found out about it when I got onto the elevator with one of my neighbors who was exultant about the potato she’d just bought.  With CartOshka just down the street, what food writer could resist?
      CartOshka, is a play on the Russian word Kartoshka for potato. It’s also used as a term of endearment as in “I love you, my little Kartoshka” and as a pejorative as slang for a gluttonous and slothful person as in “Quit acting like a Kartoshka” or so says the writing on the food cart’s side. Talk about double meanings.  CartOshka’s potato is truly something.  For $7 you get a potato that measured 6 inches long.  CartOshka then cuts the potato open from end to end.  Then the potato’s interior gets a brief fluffing followed by a big slab of butter about 4 tbsp. in size. The potato is salted and peppered and

shredded mozzarella—a lot of shredded Mozarella—is mixed in, melting immediately.   Then comes the hard part: Choosing from the immense array of add-ins.  There’s no limit to how many of these you may add.  And only one—the sausage—involves paying an extra dollar. I decided to let CartOshka pick mine.  The cook really went wild. In no particular order, he added corn, green olives, peas-and-carrots, sautéed mushrooms, chopped dill pickles, hot sauce and mayo.  I can’t say I loved it all.  But I did love bits and pieces.  The corn was great as were the mushrooms. But the olives did little for me.  The hot sauce killed every other flavor and I was glad it was confined to one small area of potato.   But oh, that melted Mozzarella which emerged from the potato in strings of cheese, clinging to the buttery potato.
         To make your own CartOshka, here’s the recipe from America’s Test Kitchen.  You’ll notice that an instant read thermometer is used to check on the internal temperature of the potato.   In true America’s Test Kitchen fashion, they’ve determined that the ideal temperature is between 205 and 212 degrees. In other words, just below the boiling point. True confession time: I don’t have an instant-read thermometer in New York.  Mine is at the beach where it gets much more use.  I’ve found that following the timing given in the recipe, my potatoes emerged from the oven and theywere flawless. The key here seems to be the instant brining–rolling the raw and pierced potato in highly salted water for a few seconds.  And secondly, the brushing of the potato with oil, or bacon or duck fat, to give the potato skin, a crispiness that’s reminiscent of the best barroom potato skins.   Here’s the recipe:

1 thought on “The Perfect Baked Potato from America’s Test Kitchen”

  • You have labeled the recipe itself as “Recipe for The Perfect Mashed Potato from America’s Test Kitchen”. I believe you mean “Baked Potato”. Ooops.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *